Home | What pit bulls can teach us about profiling | BSL and your rights





This website was created to counter the ever growing number of sources of mis-information about the American Pit Bull Terrier and American Staffordshire Terrier (commonly referred to as "pit bulls.")  Unlike the overwhelming majority of websites based on myths and hype, the information found on this website is backed up with sources and statistics.  Knowledge is power, and truth is powerful.  Please be aware of your rights, and know that you can fight for your dog.  ~ Jodi Preis, Bless the Bullys

PIT BULLS - THE TRUTH
 
 
 
~ Myth ~
Pit bull bans create a safer community. 

Denver, Colorado * Cleveland, Ohio * Hazelwood, Missouri * Lawrenceville, Georgia * Providence, Rhode Island * Boston, Massachusets * Mansfield, Ohio * Council Bluffs, Iowa * Auburn, Washington * University City, Missouri * Newport, Rhode Island * Everitt, Washington * New Bedford, Massachusets * Springfield, Missouri

The above towns banned pit bulls yet their violent crime rate remains ABOVE the national average.

In fact, since passing its pit bull ban in May 2005 the homocide rate in  Denver, Colorado has gone up in 45 of 72 Denver neighborhoods.   Further, the sexual assault rate has gone up in 49 of those same 72 neighborhoods.  (Source: Rocky Mountain News)

Prince George's County, Maryland has had a pit bull ban in place for almost a decade, however their violent crime rate continues to increase.  In 2005, there were an unprecedented number of homocides and the violent crime rate increased 16%. (Source:  Prince George's County Government Crime Reduction Strategy)








































COMMUNITIES THAT DECIDED AGAINST BANNING
PIT BULLS THIS YEAR
 
2006 Wins
 
Alabama
Montgomery - decides against BSL
 
 Arkansas
Bald Knob-decides against BSL 
Shannon Hills-decides against BSL 
Searcy-decides against BSL 
Mulberry-decides against BSL 
Fort Smith - decides against BSL
Crossett - decides against BSL
 
Colorado
SB054-doesnt pass
Golden-decides against BSL
Estes Park-decides against BSL
Northglenn-decides against BSL
Layfayette-decides against BSL
Longmont-decides against BSL
Rocky Ford-decides against BSL
Federal Heights-decides against BSL
Westminster-decides against BSL
 
Delaware
New Castle County-decides against BSL
 
Florida
Coral Springs - decides against BSL
Deltona - decides against BSL
 
Georgia
Rockmart--decides against BSL
Floyd County - decides against BSL
 
Illinois
Kewanee-decides against BSL
Waukegan-decides against BSL
McHenry County-decides against BSL
Normal-decides against BSL
Paxton-decides against BSL
Forest-decides against BSL
Bloomington-decides against BSL
Will County-decides against BSL
Chicago-decides against BSL
Lincolnshire-decides against BSL
Hodgkins-decides against BSL
Northlake - decides against BSL
Minooka - decides against BSL
 
Indiana
Anderson-decides against BSL
Indianapolis - decides against BSL
South Bend - decides against BSL
St. Joseph County - decides against BSL
 
Iowa
Mason City-decides against BSL
Waterloo-decides against BSL
Washington - decides against BSL
Humbolt - decides against BSL
 
Kansas
Leavenworth-decides against BSL
Witchita-decides against BSL
Emporia - decides against BSL
Merrium - decides against BSL
Olathe - decides against BSL
 
Kentucky
Frankfort -decides against BSL
Lietchfield-decides against BSL
Milton-decides against BSL
Lincoln County-decides against BSL
Spencer County-decides against BSL
Middlesboro-decides against BSL
Oldham County-decides against BSL
Paintsville- decides against BSL
Park Hills - decides against BSL
Corinth - decides against BSL
Taylor Mill - decides against BSL
 
Louisianna
Lake Charles-decides against BSL
Sulpher-decides against BSL
Gonzalez - decides against BSL
 
Massachusetts
Methuen - decies against BSL
Gloucester - decides against BSL
Waltham - decides against BSL
 
Michigan
Almena - BSL repealed
Cassapolis - decides against BSL
Detroit-repealed
Oxford - decides against BSL
Milford - decides against BSL
Romeo - decides against BSL
 
Mississippi
Brandon - Repealed BSL
 
Missouri
Belton-repealed
Oak Grove-decides against BSL
Bellfontaine Neighbors-decides against BSL
Unionville-decides against BSL
Jennings-decides against BSL
Raytown - decides against BSL
Sedalia - decides against BSL
University City - decides against BSL
 
New Jersey
state-TABLED
 
North Carolina
Watuga County - decides against BSL
 
Ohio
Lancaster-decides against BSL
East Palestine-decides against BSL
 
Pennsylvania
Wilkes Barre - decides against BSL
Hazelton - decides against BSL
Erie - decides against BSL
 
Tennessee
Woodbury- decides against BSL
Tullahoma - decides against BSL
Shelbyville - decides against BSL
Putnam County - decides not to pursue BSL
 
South Carolina
Bamberg - decides against BSL
 
Texas
Killeen-decides againt BSL
DeSoto - decides against BSL
 
Washington
Richland - decides against BSL
Federal Way - decides against BSL
 
West Virginia
Wheeling - decides against BSL
 
Wisconsin
Horicon - BSL vetoed
Eau Claire - decided against BSL

Essential Quotes
 
 
We've experienced a continuing upward trend of pit bulls impounded since 2001.  The ban hasn't ended the popularity of the pit bull breed in Denver. There are still pit bulls, apparently more every year.  Doug Kelley, Director of Animal Control - Denver, Colorado  
 
I think it is wrong to generalize a specific breed as vicious because it is often associated with people who break the law.  In my experience, vicious dog problems are more about people than dog... Responsible dog ownership addresses the problem far more effectively than picking on a breed.  Dr. Shawn Webster (Ohio State Representative and veterinarian) addressing members of the Ohio House Agriculture Committee on May 18, 2005.
 
[E]very dog is capable of attacking someone... People train [dogs] to fight and attack like in a cock fight. People should treat them with respect and give them some love and affection and kids like me would not get attacked.  Ryan Armstrong, courageous 7 year old victim of a dog attack and namesake of Ryan's Law.  (*To learn more about Ryan's Law, an exceptional non-breed specific dangerous dog law, please click here).
 
 
If you ban pit bulls, I promise another breed will come along as the breed of choice.   Dr. Todd Towell, President of the Colorado Veterinarian and Medical Association, addressing the Senate's Local Government Committee, January 25, 2006
 
We need to come up with something that takes care of vicious animals, not breeds.  Councilwoman Karen Halva, West Union, Iowa, October 18, 2005.
 
Having this be breed-specific makes about as much sense as me being intimidated by Commissioner (Sam) Bullock here because he's a different race," said Jason Pierce, who is white, referring to Bullock, who is black. "That's all it is, is a different breed. I don't know why we're here talking about this when we should be talking about animal cruelty and animal fighting laws."   Commissioner Jason Pierce in response to why he voted against implementing BSL in Battle Creek, Michigan on August 17, 2005.
 
"It's really about education. It's really about getting out there and letting people know what's responsible pet ownership. Our number one priority is education."  Jill Hatfield, Animal Services Superintendent, Fayetteville, Arkansas, October 20, 2005.

Those areas across the country that have pit bull bans or regulations have found that defining and identifying pit bulls can be a subjective, expensive, and time-consuming task. Numerous breeds are mistakenly identified as pit bulls, including American bulldogs, boxers, mastiffs and many other lesser-known breeds.  Adam Goldfarb, Issues Specialist with The Humane Society of the United States, October 20, 2005.
 
I don't care what kind of animal you have, whether it's a pit bull or chihuahua, that owner should be responsible if it has caused damage.  Commissioner Bob Haake, in response to why he voted against BSL in Taylor Mill, Kentucky, January 14, 2006.
 
We had some extensive discussions about [a breed specific law] and decided because of the problems of trying to identify when you say ‘pit bull,' it's very difficult to prove in a court of law. The committee thought it should not be breed-specific. It could be a pit bull, a cocker spaniel, a chihuahua, a Rottweiler, so the ordinance opts to hold owners responsible - not breeds.  Patrick Fetherson, Director of Animal Control, Cassopolis, MI, addressing the problems associated with BSL.  Cassopolis voted against a pit bull ban. 
 
 
There is no data to support the idea that a particular breed of dog is vicious, It's the owner's behavior that needs to be addressed."  Debora Bresch, legislative liaison for the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals addressing the Emporia, Kansas city council






~ Myth ~
Pit bulls are born mean
A picture is worth a thousand words...

.

Numbers Don't Lie
 
There are approximately 52 million dogs in the United States, and as many as 4.8 million are some form of pit bull.  Toledo v. Tellings (March 2006). 
 
As such, common sense would dictate that if breed of dog was the primary determining factor in all dog attacks, it would stand to reason that the statistics on pit bull bites would be astronomically high.  They simply are not.

~ MYTH ~
Pit bulls as a "breed" are dangerous
 
The Court determined that there is "little, if any, evidence presented that would indicate that" pit bulls, as a breed, are dangerous "when trained and adapted in a social situation."  (Emphasis added).  Toledo v. Tellings, 2006 WL 513946 (Ohio App. 6 Dist) March 2006.
 
The Supreme Court of Alabama affirmed the ruling of the Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit Court of Madison County, Alabama that pit bulls were not inherently dangerous, therefore, allowing four (4) pit bull puppies born in the custody of animal control to be released for adoption. 
 
 
 

Legal Milestones
 Tellings v. City of Toledo (2006)
Sixth Appellate District of Ohio Court of Appeals
 
The Court ruled that breed specific legislation was UNCONSTITUTIONAL
City of Huntsville v. Sheila Tack, et al. (2003)
Supreme Court of Alabama
The Court affirmed the lower courts ruling that pit bulls are not inherently dangerous.  
Supreme Court of Ohio
 
The Court determined that the statute that penalizes owners of
dangerous dogs who fail to buy liability insurance and properly
confine their dogs was unconstitutional for
failure to provide due process.

~ Myth ~
 
Pit bulls have locking jaws and/or massive jaw strength that can be measured in terms of pounds per square inch (PSI).  
 
Dr. I. Lerh Brisbin, Ph.D as well as other experts, testified that pit bulls do not have locking jaws.  Based on actual dog dissections and measurements of their skulls, the evidence demonstrated that pit bull jaw muscles and bone structure are the same as other similarly sized dogs. 
 
No evidence was presented to demonstrate that a pit bull’s bite is any stronger than other dogs of its size and build. 
 
Dr. Brisbin testified that contrary to information relied upon and perpetuated by earlier case law and law review articles, assertions that a pit bull can bite with a “force of 2,000 pounds per square inch” have absolutely no basis in fact or scientific proof.  The testing of dog bite strength has never been done and would be difficult, if not impossible, to perform.   Toledo v. Tellings, 2006 WL 513946 (Ohio App. 6 Dist), March 2006
 
(Dr. I. Lerh Brisbin, Ph.D., Senior Research Scientist with Savanna River Ecology Laboratory and University of South Carolina professor; Expert in behavior, training and handling of pit bull terriers and their anatomy)
 
 
~ Myth ~
 
Pit bulls have a stronger bite than other large dog breeds.
 
There is no scientific evidence showing pit bulls to have a stronger bite than other large dog breeds.  In fact, when Dr. Brady Barr of National Geographic (Dangerous Encounters: Bite Force, 8/18/2005) measured the bite forces of three dog breeds (Rottweiler, German Shepherd Dog and American Pit Bull Terrier) using a computerized bite sleeve, the American Pit Bull Terrier generated the least amount of pressure out of the 3 dogs tested.   
 

_________________________
 
Identification Issues
_________________________

Among the many problems associated with breed specific legislation and its enforcement against pit bulls are the issues associated with identification.  "Pit bull" is not a breed, but rather a generic term used to describe the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier and Staffordshire Bull Terrier.  However, the physical traits and characteristics shared by "pit bulls" are also shared by approximately twenty-five (25) other breeds that are not typically classified as bully breed dogs.  Obviously, this causes great difficulty in identification and allows for discriminatory and subjective actions by animal control officers.
 
Clicking on the picture below will take you to a "game" called 'Find the Pit Bull," which is an excellent tool to demonstrate the difficulty of identifing a purebred American Pit Bull Terrier.    

find3.jpg

Ohio dog warden, Tom Skeldon, who was called as an "expert" on behalf of the City of Toledo in the matter of Toledo v. Tellings testified that there is really no way to tell if a dog is or is not a pit bull, and the determination is made by animal control officers' subjective judgment.  Toledo v. Tellings, 2006 WL 513946 (Ohio App. 6 Dist) March 2006
 
[Breed bans] carry with them too much potential for arbitrary or improper enforcement:  inaccurate breed identification by officials and difficulty enforcing breed bans against mixed-breed.  Source:  AnimalLaw
 
[W]e conclude that the subjective identification of pit bulls may often include both non-pit bulls or dogs which are not vicious...[laws] based upon that identification process, we conclude that they are unconstitutionally vague.  Toledo v. Tellings, 2006 WL 513946 (Ohio App. 6 Dist) March 2006

Pit bulls in the Spotlight
 
Breed bans have been shown to be ineffective and cost prohibitive and have little or no positive impact on public health and safety. 
 
Communities considering breed specific legislation can trace dog problems directly to three (3) factors:
  • lack of aggresive, government-subsidized spay/neuter programs targeting low-income residents;
  • no humane education programs; and
  • need for better enforcement of existing animal ordinances.

Source:  Humane Association of the United States 

The UNconstitutionally of BSL
pursuant to the March 2006 ruling in
Toledo v. Tellings*
 
 
*Please note, the City of Toledo has appealed the Appelate Court's ruling to the Supreme Court of Ohio.  As such, the Appellate Court's decision is stayed.

Breed Profiling, the Equivalent to Racial Profiling
 
Excerpts taken from Malcolm Gladwell's article in the New Yorker, What pit bulls can teach us about profiling
 
When we say that pit bulls are dangerous, we are making a generalization, just as insurance companies use generalizations when they charge young men more for car insurance than the rest of us (even though many young men are perfectly good drivers), and doctors use generalizations when they tell overweight middle-aged men to get their cholesterol checked (even though many overweight middle-aged men won’t experience heart trouble). Because we don’t know which dog will bite someone or who will have a heart attack or which drivers will get in an accident, we can make predictions only by generalizing.
 
Another word for generalization, though, is “stereotype,” and stereotypes are usually not considered desirable dimensions of our decision-making lives.
 






Temperament Test Results
 
The American Temperament Test Society conducts tests every year on thousands of dogs to determine the soundness of their temperament.  The American Pit Bull Terrier and the American Staffordshire Terrier routinely and consistently rank in the average range, and well above many "popular" breeds such as the beagle, collie, doberman pinscher, cocker spaniel and great dane.  (Source:  American Temperament Test Society) 
 
 
 Alfons Estelt of the American Temperament Test Society, Inc., stated the following with respect to pit bulls: "The American Pit Bull Terriers participating in our temperament evaluation have thus far shown a passing rate of 95%. The other 121 breeds of dogs in our tests showed the average passing rate of 77%"
 

Communities that have repealed pit bulls bans because they were found to be (1) too costly; (2) difficult to enforce and (3) ineffective:
 
Belton, Missouri
Bourbonnais, Illinois
Detroit, Michigan
East Point, Michigan
Redford, Michigan
Beloit, Kansas
Alguna, Washington
Hudsonville, Michigan
Baltimore, Maryland
Saginaw, Michigan
 
 

Organizations Against BSL

Humane Society of the United States (HSUS)

American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)

American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA)

National Animal Control Association (NACA)

American Humane

American Kennel Club (AKC)

National Association of Dog Obedience Instructors (NADOI)

Association of Pet Dog Trainers (APDT)

American Dog Owners Association (ADOA)

National Animal Interest Alliance (NAIA)

International Assocation of Animal Behavior Consultants (IAABC)

American Working Dog Federation (AWDF)

National Animal Interest Aliance

Australian National Kennel Council

American Kennel Club

Canadian Kennel Club

Canadian Federation of Humane Societies

Chicago Veterinary Medical Association

Wilmington Kennel Club

Louisiana Veterinary Medical Association

Ottowa Humane Society

Nova Scotia SPCA

International Association of Animal Behavior

American Animal Hospital Association

Colorado Federal of Animal Welfare Agencies

Animal Sheltering

Wisconsin Federated Human Societies

Ontario Veterinary Medical Association

World Small Animal Veterinary Association

Metropolitan Washington Council of Government

The College of Veterinarians of Ontario

 

~ RECAP ~
2004 NAIA Dangerous Dog Conference
 
NAIA recognizes that efforts to reduce dog bites fail because citizens, lawmakers and humane groups tend to emphasize laws and policies that restrict dog ownership rather than penalize irresponsible dog owners. 
 
Speaker Robert Gloster, M.D., FACEP, stated, "When communities confront the problem of dangerous dogs, they often depend heavily on outdated lists of dog related deaths that put pit bulls and rottweilers at the top."
 
A dangerous dog is only a symptom of the real problem:  irresponsible owners that don't understand dog behavior and cruel and criminal owners who damage dogs and make them dangerous.  ...breed specific legislation is an inappropriate response to what is an issue of irresponsible ownership.  Jane Berkey, President, Animal Farm Foundation. 
 
While [BSL] addresses a legislators immediate political emergency, it creates in the public a false sense of security and diverts needed resources from real solutions.  It has a devasating effect upon innocent owners and dogs, as well as the agencies left to cope with the flood of "cast offs."  Jane Berkey
 
Breed specific laws create challenges for shelter managers.  We can be overwhelmed by BSL.  Andy Mahlman, Manager, SPCA Cincinnati
 
We prosecute people not dogs.  Often dogs categorized as "vicious" or "dangerous" are just acting like dogs.  Pam Sears, Hamilton County Ohio prosecutor.
 
Animal control is a band-aid.  Education is important to prevention.  Nancy Hill, Director, Spokane Washington Animal Control
 
The dangerous dog problem is a result of irresponsible owners, the popularity of powerful breeds and inadequate laws to address dangerous or vicious dogs.  Nancy Hill
 
Conclusions of the Seminar
 
1.  The problems caused by dangerous dogs in the community must be identified before they can be resolved.
 
2.  Responsible dog owners are part of any solution and should be recognized for their contributions to the community.
 
3.  The media is an important part of every solution because [the media] can either drive the hysteria or highlight problems and potential solutions.
 
4.  Dog advocates must promote responsible dog ownership.
 
5.  When laws are proposed, dog owners must stand up and make their views known, work with legislators, and offer alternatives to BSL.
 

BSL and the Cost to Taxpayers
 
1.  Cost of additional animal control offers to enforce the ban or restrictions.  **Remember, most cities do not have sufficient animal control departments to enforce leash laws, which if enforced would reduce many of the problems that lead to bite incidents.
 
2.  Kennelling.
 
3.  Veterinary care of the animals.  (Ho